Job protectionism is not a valid economic system… well, at least not one that will work.
Initially, an objection by Supervisor Norman Yee to delivery robots on San Francisco streets was that they would eliminate delivery jobs. However, protectionism such as this is bad; freeing workers up for other higher-level functions (like designing, building or repairing delivery robots) while automating low-paying jobs and eliminating street traffic results in higher productivity and lower costs for all – a boon to any economy.Unfortunately, things only went downhill from there; later revisions of the proposal went so far as to require that delivery companies “keep a human nearby to monitor the devices and agree to a labor clause protecting their human workers’ right to unionize.” (emphasis mine).
OK – somebody’s got to say it: this proposal is complete lunacy. I just hope that Yee’s constituents are smart enough to see past his short-sighted protectionist legislation.